Creator Campaign KPI Cheat Sheet

How to Track KPIs According to Campaign Type

Creator campaigns are easy to launch and hard to measure. Most brands and agencies track something, but not always the right things. Likes and views feel good, but hey don’t always tell you if the campaign worked. A giveaway shouldn’t be measured like an affiliate program. A brand ambassador partnership shouldn’t be judged on one post’s engagement. ‍

CreatorCatalyst.ai offers different "Campaign Type" options, listed below, in our AI Campaign module on app.creatorcatalyst.ai. Sign up today for a free trial.

Sponsored Content

Use this campaign type when the goal is reach, awareness, or brand perception.‍

Primary KPIs

• Impressions
• Reach
• Video views (platform-specific definitions matter)

Supporting KPIs

• Engagement rate
• CPM
• Follower growth during campaign window

What to watch out for

• High impressions with weak engagement often signal poor creator-brand fit or overly restrictive briefs.

Campaigns like this work best when the brief is clear but flexible. If briefs are slowing you down, the AI campaign setup inside creatorcatalyst.ai/product is designed to remove that friction.

Gifting / Giveaway Campaigns

Best for discovery, early traction, and community growth.

Primary KPIs

• Participation volume (entries, comments, tags)
• Engagement rate
• Follower growth

Supporting KPIs

• Profile visits
• New email or SMS signups (if applicable)

What to watch out for:‍

• Giveaways can inflate low-intent engagement. Measure quality signals, not just volume.

Affiliate / Commission-Based Campaigns

Use this campaign type when performance and revenue are the priority.

Primary KPIs

• Click-through rate (CTR)
• Conversions (sales, installs, signups)
• Cost per conversion

Supporting KPIs

• Revenue per creator
• Conversion rate by platform

What to watch out for

• Creators convert differently than ads. Look at trends across creators instead of expecting uniform performance.

Content (UGC) Campaigns

These campaigns are about acquiring reusable assets, not public distribution.

Primary KPIs

• Number of usable assets delivered
• Content quality and alignment with brief
• Usage rights secured

Supporting KPIs

• Time to delivery
• Performance when repurposed for paid or organic

What to watch out for

• If usage rights aren’t clearly defined, even strong content becomes unusable.

Brand Ambassador / Partnership Campaigns

Designed for long-term brand affinity rather short-term spikes in engagement.

Primary KPIs

• Performance consistency over time
• Creator retention
• Audience sentiment and comment quality

Supporting KPIs

• Repeat conversions
• Cost efficiency across multiple deliverables

What to watch out for

• Judging these partnerships on a single post leads to bad decisions. Look at trends, not snapshots.

Pro-Tip:

Tracking creator-level performance across campaigns is easier when discovery, outreach, and campaign history live in one system -- something CreatorCatalyst was built to support (creatorcatalyst.ai/product).

Event or Experience Activations

Best for launches, pop-ups, conferences, and in-person brand moments.

Primary KPIs

• Event attendance driven by creators
• Content volume during the event
• Reach during event window

Supporting KPIs

• Story views
• Mentions and tags
• Post-event traffic spikes

What to watch out for

• Timing matters more than polish. Late posts reduce impact dramatically.

Creator-Level KPIs (Across All Campaign Types)

These help you build a reliable creator roster.

• Outreach response rate
• On-time delivery
• Brief adherence
• Ease of collaboration
• Performance consistency

Campaign-Level KPIs (Zoomed Out)

These show whether your workflow is improving.

• Time from brief creation to first post
• Cost per creator partnership
• Campaign completion rate
• ROI by campaign type

Final Thoughts

There’s no universal KPI framework for creator marketing. Each campaign type demands different signals, timelines, and expectations.

When KPIs are aligned with intent and tracked consistently, campaign performance becomes easier to understand and easier to improve.

If you want to build campaigns where KPIs are defined from the start, explore the CreatorCatalyst workflow at creatorcatalyst.ai/product.

Related reads:

• How to Build a Full Creator Campaign in 15 Minutes With AI
• The Fastest Way to Create a Campaign Brief (No Templates Needed)
• Instagram Reels vs. Tiktok: Which Is Better For Your Next Campaign?

‍